The Five Shifts · Instalment 5 of 5: From Solo Leadership to Shared Leadership

A significant proposal landed at short notice a few weeks ago. The kind that asks everything of a small team in a compressed window of time.

I could have white-knuckled through it alone. That would have been my default not long ago.

Instead, Sharon stepped up in ways I didn’t anticipate and couldn’t have scripted. The team picked up the slack around us, creating the space to focus and do the work properly. What came out the other end was better than anything I could have produced by myself. Not just faster. Actually better.

I’ve been sitting with that since.

This is the fifth and final instalment in a series called The Five Shifts, drawn from Arrow 2035 research into what faithful Christian leadership requires in Australia right now. We’ve looked at the shifts from performing credibility to embodying it, from information to formation, from productivity to presence, and from institutional assumption to earned trust. This month, the shift is from solo leadership to shared leadership.

There are three realities underneath that shift. This time, they feel personal.

Reality 1: The leader you become alone is a diminished version of who you could be

The Arrow 2035 research keeps returning to a pattern that is quietly alarming. Leaders leaving ministry and senior roles not primarily because of external pressure — not the board conflict or the budget crisis or the cultural shift — but because there was no one who truly knew them. The isolation wasn’t a symptom of failure. It was the condition that made failure more likely.

Ecclesiastes puts it with characteristic bluntness. Two are better than one, because they have a good return for their labour. If either of them falls down, one can help the other up. But pity anyone who falls and has no one to help them up. A cord of three strands is not quickly broken.

The leader who functions alone can sustain output for a long time. We’ve established that across this series — the performing leader, the information-accumulating leader, the productively busy leader, the institutionally credible leader. All of them capable of running hard for a season on solo reserves. What they cannot sustain, over the long arc, is formation.

Solo leadership isn’t just lonely.

The leader shaped only by their own perspective, their own counsel, their own interior echo chamber becomes a narrower version of what they could have been. That narrowing is often only visible looking back.

Reality 2: Being genuinely known is harder than it looks and more necessary than we admit

I want to be honest about something that I don’t find easy to say.

I want to be seen as competent. I want to look like I know what I’m doing. There is something in me that finds it genuinely costly to let the guard down — to admit uncertainty to people whose respect I value, to name the weight I’m carrying to someone who might revise their opinion of me because of it. That cost is real. I’ve felt it. I still feel it.

And yet the moments in my leadership where something has genuinely shifted have almost always happened in the presence of people who know me well enough to see past the competence I’m performing. My mentor Sheldon. A female CEO peer group I’ve been part of for some time — and have been missing lately, more than I’d like to admit. My supervisor. A few close friends and colleagues who know the difference between how I present and how I actually am.

Being known feels different from being respected. When I am genuinely known — seen, heard, understood — there’s a quality of steadiness that doesn’t come from anywhere else. A settledness. Something close to peace. It’s not that the problems are smaller. It’s that I’m not carrying them in a sealed room by myself.

It costs something to get there. Letting people see behind the role, behind the capability, behind the version of yourself you’ve curated — that requires a kind of trust that doesn’t come easily, particularly for leaders whose identity is bound up in being capable. It also costs something different to maintain. Community of that quality doesn’t sustain itself. It requires time, honesty, and a willingness to keep showing up even when the season is busy enough to make showing up feel impossible.

I’ve let some of that slide. I’m naming it here because I suspect I’m not alone in that.

Reality 3: Shared leadership isn’t a weakness — it’s the only kind that lasts

Back to the proposal.

Sharon was extraordinary. The team was extraordinary. And what struck me afterwards wasn’t gratitude, though I felt that too. It was the recognition that something had been produced in shared effort that genuinely wouldn’t have existed in the same form had I carried it alone. The thinking was sharper. The work was better. The pressure, distributed across people who each brought something I don’t have, became manageable rather than crushing.

That’s what shared leadership actually produces. Not a divided load but something genuinely greater than the sum of its parts.

Jesus’ words in Matthew 11 have been sitting with me. Come to me, all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you. For my yoke is easy and my burden is light. I used to read that as a promise about effort, that following Jesus would somehow require less of me. I don’t think that’s it. A yoke is designed for two. The ease is something to do with not carrying the weight in a sealed room by yourself.

By 2035, the leaders who are still standing, still formed, still genuinely present to the people and work they’re called to — they won’t be the ones who were the most individually capable or the most resilient in isolation. They’ll be the ones who learned, sometimes reluctantly, to lead from within genuine community. Who let themselves be known. Who shared the yoke.

Arrow’s entire approach is a bet on this. Small cohort, peer-formed, practicum-based, spiritually anchored formation — because we genuinely believe that what happens between leaders, in the space of honest community, produces something that no individual program or private discipline can replicate alone. We’ve seen it across thirty years and more than a thousand participants. It’s not a theory anymore.

Five shifts. Five months. One underlying movement underneath all of them.

From performing to embodying. From information to formation. From productive busyness to genuine presence. From borrowed trust to earned character. From solo to held.

The proposal got submitted. Sharon was amazing. The team held something together that I couldn’t have held alone, and in the holding, something was built that wouldn’t have existed otherwise.

That’s what this series has been trying to say, from five different angles, across five different moments in my own leadership. You don’t become who you need to be by yourself. Formation is a community project. And the leaders Australia will need in 2035 are being shaped right now, in the honest, inconvenient spaces where people actually know each other.

If any part of this series has resonated, I’d love to invite you to explore what Arrow offers. Both our Emerging Leaders and Executive Leaders programs are currently taking recommendations and applications. These aren’t courses. They’re the kind of community this series has been describing — spaces where leaders are genuinely known and formed together, then sent back to their contexts with something they couldn’t have found alone.

You can find out more at arrowleadership.org.au.

A question to sit with as the series closes: who knows you well enough to tell you the truth — and when did you last let them?

A note on process: I use AI tools to support my writing. The ideas, stories, and voice are my own.